Brand

Nutter Butter

Nutter Butter products ranked by Reviews and Health.

Cookies
No. 1 · Best overallNutter Butter Sandwich Cookies 16 ozCookies57No. 2 · Most lovedNutter Butter Sandwich Cookies 16 ozCookies84No. 3 · Cleanest signalNutter Butter Wafer Peanut Pattie 10.5 oz 500 OzCookies36

Reviews app

Shop Nutter Butter with the score open.

Compare Reviews Score, Health Score, ingredients, and cleaner swaps before it lands in your cart.

Join waitlist

Scorecards

Nutter Butter products

Every product links into its shelf, alternatives, and full scorecard.

1

Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies 16 oz

Nutter Butter
2

Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies Family Size 15.27 oz

Nutter Butter
3

Nutter Butter Wafer Peanut Pattie 10.5 oz 500 Oz

Nutter Butter
4

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies 11.8 oz

Nutter Butter
5

Nutter Butter Single Serve Sandwich Bites 3 oz

Nutter Butter
6

Nutter Butter Cookies Supermix 4.8 oz

Nutter Butter

Explore

More ways into Nutter Butter

Brand shelves

Cookies 6

Compare

Better alternatives to Nutter ButterBest CookiesDaily trending productsLoved by ReviewsJoin the waitlist